…n. On the stock market, both have a similar beta of 0.7, but political risk weighs only on one side; so from a risk perspective, mainly for not having the government's meddling finger, due to the risk of that absent finger, point for Prio. And from Inside's view, both have a buy recommendation. Petrobras has an upside potential of 34.2%, and both are below their price ceiling, so you can buy either one. Kind of with your eyes closed regarding these multiples, and from Inside's perspective, Petrobras's third quarter came in line with our expectations due to pre-salt growth, refining recovery, and low multiples that support a favorable risk…
And from Inside's view, both have a buy recommendation. Petrobras has an upside potential of 34.2%, and both are below their price ceiling, so you can buy either one.
Contexto extraído por IA
And from Inside's view, both have a buy recommendation. Petrobras has an upside potential of 34.2%, and both are below their price ceiling, so you can buy either one. Kind of with your eyes closed regarding these multiples, and from Inside's perspective, Petrobras's third quarter came in line with our expectations due to pre-salt growth, refining recovery, and low multiples that support a favorable risk-return ratio with a very attractive carry through dividends.
Transcrição Completa
What’s up, you deep-well drillers. How are you doing? I hope you’re doing great. Today we’re having a little duel, my friend, between a state giant, Petrobras , and a private newcomer. I prefer the private ones. Comment below if you prefer the state-owned one with the missing pinky or a very well-managed private rookie. Prio is in our Elite Inside portfolio and really held its ground during these dips. It significantly reduced the portfolio’s beta, the portfolio’s volatility. Just a reminder that our Black Friday event is on, so it’s 90%off for my team to manage your portfolio. Give us a vote of confidence, and we’ll fix that mess you’ve put together. Deal? While I record the screen, go ahead and leave that like. Look, it doesn’t cost anything. I’m making so many videos, this is a lot of work. Leave a like, comment any nonsense, which of the two you prefer, anything so the algorithm understands my content isn’t that irrelevant. Well, regarding stock prices, oil gave, and the election took away. So, in 12 months, you can see here, both rode the oil wave. Brent went up 49%, Prio up 59%, and Petrobras 37%, against only 9%for the Ibovespa. And then after the second round, both fell along with the market, but Petrobras dropped 24%against 14%for Petrorio. And these are companies of very different sizes, so you can see here by their market cap. Petrobras is worth 620 billion BRL, while Prio is worth 50 billion. And Petrobras produces 18 times more oil , but is worth only 12 times more on the stock exchange. And the question of this little duel is which of the two oil companies is more worth it right now. So, there are six rounds using just numbers. And if you look at this X-ray here, putting both balance sheets side by side , look, everything’s green. For those who are colorblind, I’m pointing out here that both came in with totally excellent results. So, Petrobras is more integrated; despite being state-owned, it extracts oil from the sea, refines, transports, and sells the fuel. And PRIO is private , and it only produces. So, it basically buys fields that have already been discovered and squeezes efficiency out of them. So, both have very controlled debt here , almost equivalent to 1 year of operating profit, very interesting margins, but anyway, let’s get to this sneaky little duel. Well, the first round is about growth. So, when you think about who grew the most, PRIO won here, and by a landslide . It’s not even a comparison. PRIO doubled its production in one year and multiplied its profit by almost six. We’re talking about just the last year here. So, it was the effect of getting a PRIO field up and running, operational. And the fact that they bought the field . As for Petrobras, they grew well for their size, growing 11.7%driven by new pre-salt platforms, but for someone already producing 3.5 million barrels a day, doubling like PRIO did here is impossible. There isn't even enough oil demand for them to double. So, a point for PRIO on the growth front. In round two, we ask who extracts oil from the depths more cheaply. Petrobras is at $ 6.12 per barrel, while PRIO needs $ 7.90 to extract oil, but their extraction cost fell 54.5%in one year, which is a historical low for PRIO . So, they are getting very close to the cost of pulling a barrel from the seabed , excluding taxes and investments. It’s like the production cost of a farm . The lower it is, the more the company can withstand when prices drop. So, with higher margins because it costs less to extract the oil, Petrobras wins because it has the pre-salt, which are gigantic, very productive fields where the barrel comes out at $ 4.48, but PRIO did an impressive job, cutting costs in half in one year, though they still spend 29%more per barrel. In practical terms, with Brent at $ 96, which is what it's trading at as I record this video, both make a lot of money per barrel, so they're safe. And the difference appears when oil prices plummet. A year ago, Brent oil was at 64 bucks, and that's when low costs separate those who profit from those who suffer. So PRIO is doing an exquisite job here, but Petrobras manages to extract at a lower cost, so a point for Petrobras. In terms of margins, we look at who turns more revenue into cash, and PRIO won here. It rose 21 percentage points in one year , with an EBITDA margin of 78%—this is absurd compared to Petrobras '55.8%. And if you look historically, PRIO has a higher EBITDA margin, so PRIO keeps 78 reais in EBITDA for every 100 reais sold . Petrobras keeps 56. Part of the difference is the model. So Petrobras also refines and sells fuel, and refining has lower margins than production. PRIO only produces and sells crude oil, so the outlier for PRIO was 2025, when the margin dropped to 49%here, with the asset still under construction and high costs. So it has to spend a lot of CAPEX to improve the efficiency of the wells it buys, but once it's up and running, things get crazy. So, a point for PRIO. In round four, we have dividends, and there’s no comparison here; it’s the easiest round of the duel. Petrobras reached a 59%dividend yield in 2022, so those who bought in 2022 received 59 reais in dividends for every 100 reais invested. And according to Inside's projections, the dividend yield should return to double digits in 2026 and 2027, while PRIO has never been a good dividend payer because it’s the baby of the group . It uses its cash to grow, pay down debt , and buy back shares. Share buybacks are a great way for a company to increase value, because it reduces the number of shares circulating on the stock exchange. So, for those who own the stock, since it becomes scarcer , each share should be worth more. So, in the third quarter of 2026, it bought back 6.1 million shares for 71 million dollars, which is about 0.8%of the company in a single quarter. Therefore, the buyback also returns money to the shareholder, because each share becomes worth a larger piece of the company. But for those who want income hitting their account, there’s no debate. So, a big point here for Petrobras. And in round six, we look at who is cheaper, who trades at lower multiples. In this case, Petrobras has a P/E of 3.8 times the profit projected by Inside and an EV/EBITDA of 2.5 times, while Prio has a price-to-earnings of 5.6 times and an EV/EBITDA of 2.8 times. So, both are cheap and are priced low, but Petrobras is cheaper, a better bargain. So, paying 44.7 per share, the profit projected for 2026 recovers the price in less than 4 years, and in Prio's case, in almost 6. But take a look here at the projected P/E for 2027 . Prio's profit practically stops growing in the Inside projection, growing only 1%, while Petrobras rises 13%. That's because Prio's big production jump has already happened in 2026. So, one more for Petrobras. In round seven, we look at risk. So, who gives us fewer scares? And here is Prio from the perspective of beta, that indicator that tells you how much you won't soil your pants when the stock drops; it falls less because it's private and only carries operational risk, not risk from Brasília. So, Petrobras's numbers are better in almost every way, but it has a partner that doesn't give a damn about profit, which is the government. So, the government chooses the company president and influences the price of gasoline and diesel, as well as investments and dividends. After the runoff election, Petrobras fell 24%more than the Ibovespa and Prio . For example, in the balance sheet itself , part of the 12.7 billion stuck in working capital this quarter are receivables from fuel subsidies, which is a government program screwing them over. So Prio doesn't have that problem , but it has its own. The issues with Prio are that it depends on few fields, the Bravo cluster remains affected by a well shutdown, and maritime freight costs have risen. On the stock market, both have a similar beta of 0.7, but political risk weighs only on one side; so from a risk perspective, mainly for not having the government's meddling finger, due to the risk of that absent finger, point for Prio. And from Inside's view, both have a buy recommendation. Petrobras has an upside potential of 34.2%, and both are below their price ceiling, so you can buy either one. Kind of with your eyes closed regarding these multiples, and from Inside's perspective, Petrobras's third quarter came in line with our expectations due to pre-salt growth, refining recovery, and low multiples that support a favorable risk-return ratio with a very attractive carry through dividends. Regarding Prio, the third quarter exceeded expectations with record production, costs at a minimum, and debt falling fast, plus new blocks and a well in Frade that add new growth options. So the final score ended in a tie. And choosing between the two depends on your profile. I have a Prio profile, but for those who want income, go with Petrobras; it's cheaper, and the price of being cheap is having the government as a partner. The point of attention is that both depend on international oil prices; Brent dropped from 118 dollars to 96 dollars in three weeks, and every dollar less per barrel comes straight out of both their profits, so that's the sector risk they all end up having. That's it for today's video. A kiss to your hearts, and let's go make some money. I'm out.
Comentários 0
Entre para participar da discussão.
EntrarAinda não há comentários. Seja o primeiro a compartilhar sua opinião!