A elétrica mais barata da bolsa hoje ⚡🔌 ENERGISA x ENGIE

A elétrica mais barata da bolsa hoje ⚡🔌 ENERGISA x ENGIE

Analyzed Watch on YouTube Requested On
Video return
+2.22%
Calls
1
Buy / Sell
1 0
Published

Recommendations

Entry is the asset's closing price on the publication date. Current is the last close on record.

  1. ENGI11 B3 BUY +2.22%
    Entry R$47.39 12 Nov 2026
    Current R$48.44 19 Nov 2026
    Result +R$1.05
    vs. index +5.1% BOVA11 −2.9% over the same days
    Surrounding source transcript
    …BITDA, which includes debt, Energisa is cheaper. And round seven, which is the final one , is what our analysts at INSADE Research say. So, Energisa has greater appreciation potential here for its shares, with an upside potential of 25.6%. The recommendation is a "buy two" with a fair price of R $ 60, and it is currently trading below the ceiling price of R $ 60 as well, with a 10% margin of safety in this case. So, if we had to choose one of the two, not only because of the final score of five to two for Energisa, but in terms of valuation, we would opt for Energisa . For Inside, the third quarter came in above expectations; the distribution mark…

    The recommendation is a "buy two" with a fair price of R $ 60, and it is currently trading below the ceiling price of R $ 60 as well, with a 10% margin of safety in this case.

    AI-extracted context So, Energisa has greater appreciation potential here for its shares, with an upside potential of 25.6%. The recommendation is a "buy two" with a fair price of R $ 60, and it is currently trading below the ceiling price of R $ 60 as well, with a 10% margin of safety in this case.

Full Transcript
What’s up, you electrocuted Pederneirases. Who remembers Pederneiras when he was doing an interview and out of nowhere he touches a grapevine, or whatever he was doing, he touches it and twists his whole body. That video is wonderful. Well, today we’re going to have a duel here between our darling Engie, which I’ve already recorded about 70 videos of on this channel, against Energisa. And why did I decide to record this video? Because they are in the same sector, the electric sector, but they are in different subsectors. And I also decided to record this video because many people confuse Engie’s ticker with Energisa’s, because Engie is EGIE3 and Energisa is ENGI. And so, people must be loaded with Energisa because they bought the wrong one, you little pest. Remembering that we are in the Blackest of Blacks here with 90%off. My team will take care of your portfolio , so you can send that mess you’ve built over and we’ll gradually adjust your portfolios to take advantage of the best opportunities in the stock market. So let’s get to the video. A picturesque duel between Engie and Energisa. Well, in the stock market, as usual, both suffered a hell of a rollercoaster . So Energisa fell 28.1%after the second round and Engie fell 14.1%, and Energisa was clearly the stock most sensitive to the election, as it rose 24%in the week of the first round and gave it all back after the second, falling 28 percent. So, energy distributors live by government rules, like tariff adjustments and concession renewals. And the market priced in more regulatory risk, more risk of sudden government intervention to try to control inflation . And Engie, which is a generator, fluctuated less, but it is 14%lower than a year ago. And the question of this picturesque duel is, after the tumble, which utility is more worth it? So there are seven rounds with numbers only. And if you look here, through the X-ray I did for you folks, with both balance sheets side by side, you can see that Energisa has a lot more green stuff here , a lot more green indicators. These indicators are almost all from and to me this is the most important information for the shareholder, the most important financial information, but with these higher interest rates, it also became very important to look at the companies 'cash flow and we will discuss each of these points here in this video. So, just to provide context, regarding Energisa, the energy distributed grew with the heat, driven by residential consumption which rose 14.1%and by commerce which rose 10.7%. In August, it sold five transmission concessions to recycle capital, and for Engie, hydroelectric plants generated 11.4% more while the Jirau plant started contributing. So, Engie made several past investments that are now starting to make sense, but the villain for Engie is curtailment, which happens when there is a lack of transmission lines or excess energy on the grid, and the system operator tells Engie to shut down its wind and solar farms. It is more or less like having a ready-to-run factory and being forced to stop the machines. And in the third quarter, 26%of potential wind and solar generation was curtailed, compared to 23 %a year ago. So it is important to see that the stock market isn't just about numbers, but here we will hold seven rounds of conflict between Energisa and Engie. And the first round is who grew the most . And here Energisa beats Engie because it had an adjusted profit of 792 million reais and a recurring EBITDA that rose 17.4%, whereas Engie's fell 2.1%. It had an adjusted profit of 716 million and an EBITDA that rose only 4.1%. So in terms of EBITDA and adjusted profit, Energisa accelerated while Engie moved sideways. Energisa nearly doubled its profit, driven by more distributed energy, controlled expenses, and lower interest on its debt. So, excluding the sold transmission assets, comparable EBITDA grew by 19.5% . On the other hand, Engie sold more energy, but the results did not follow suit. The depreciation of its equipment rose 19.7%, interest expenses increased, and the result from TAG, the gas pipeline company it has a stake in, fell 13.3%, so the point goes to Energisa. In round two, we look at margins. So, who improved their margins the most? Energisa wins here too because it grew four percentage points, from 27.1%to 31.1%, while Engie saw its EBITDA margin fall by 2.9 percentage points, but note that it started from a very high base, moving from 56%to 53.1%, so we must be careful with this direct comparison because generators like Engie always have higher margins, as distributors pass on the cost of energy purchased from generators in electricity bills, which inflates revenue without becoming profit. That is why what matters here is the direction. So I prioritized the evolution. Energisa's margin rose four points, while Engie's fell nearly three due to the curtailment we mentioned earlier and higher energy purchases. For round three, we take indebtedness into account. So, who is more comfortable with debt? Energisa wins here too. It has a net debt to EBITDA of 2.95 x, which is high, but not so high for the sector if you look at the companies, especially the transmission ones that are performing worse on the stock market ; it's actually safe, and Engie's net debt to EBITDA is at 3.1 x. As you can see here, Energisa has always been a much more indebted company, but its debt is falling while Engie is still going through some struggles. So, from this debt perspective, there was also a narrow victory for Energisa, which went from 3.84 to 2.95 with the help of the sale of its transmission assets. But its average cost of debt is still high, at 13.84%per year. This debt is quite expensive, especially because the electric sector is able to borrow at lower interest rates due to a level of predictability that characterizes the sector, and Engie, which was always less leveraged, reached 3.1 x and stalled there with rising financial expenses. For round four, we'll think about profitability, so, who makes capital yield more? So, here Engie wins without question. It yields more on invested capital in every year of the series, both by ROIC and ROI. The plants already built and with contracted energy generate a lot of cash per real invested . The warning here is the drop from 13.6 to 9.2 in 2025, also due to curtailment and higher debt. Round five is the fan favorite for you who already have a significant amount of money in each of these companies. So, from the dividend perspective, the one who pays more is Engie, projected at 7.7%for this year and it should go to 9.3%in 2027, and Engie is the traditional payer. It paid more than Energisa in three of the last five years and INSADE projections point to almost double the dividend yield in 2026 and 2027. Energisa had a peak of 9.9%in 2025, which is where it beat Engie, but its priority is to invest in the network and reduce debt. Regarding price, since everyone wants to buy a good and cheap company, Energisa proves to be much cheaper. Today it trades at 7.8 times price-to-earnings versus 13.1 times. So, according to INSADE's projections for 2026, Engie seems much cheaper, but they require earnings per share 72% higher than in 2025, in a quarter where profit fell 2.1 percent. So, based on what the companies are delivering today, the math flips, because Energisa currently costs 7.8 times its annualized earnings against 13.1 times for Engie, and also in EV over EBITDA, which includes debt, Energisa is cheaper. And round seven, which is the final one , is what our analysts at INSADE Research say. So, Energisa has greater appreciation potential here for its shares, with an upside potential of 25.6%. The recommendation is a "buy two" with a fair price of R $ 60, and it is currently trading below the ceiling price of R $ 60 as well, with a 10% margin of safety in this case. So, if we had to choose one of the two, not only because of the final score of five to two for Energisa, but in terms of valuation, we would opt for Energisa . For Inside, the third quarter came in above expectations; the distribution market is accelerating, EBITDA is growing, and debt is falling, which forms a favorable combination for value creation. So the upcoming tariff reviews should recognize the investments in the remuneration base of the distributors, as is the case with Energisa. And in Engie's case, the result was in line, and Inside recognizes the quality of the portfolio and the predictability of the contracts, but curtailment and leverage should continue to pressure them without enough asymmetry for a more constructive view. So the final score was five to two for Energisa, and I just wanted to highlight a point of attention here: power companies are sensitive to interest rates. With the Selic at 13.75%and the Copom with no set date to start cutting interest rates again, fixed income ends up competing directly with the sector's dividends. We will continue to follow these two wonderful companies in a wonderful sector, but today Energisa was the winner. Got it? Check if you're subscribed to the channel, comment which of the two you invest in, or if you're going to start investing in either, our recommendation is to prioritize Energisa . That's it for this video, a kiss in your hearts, and let's go make some money. I'm out.

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!